Methanol Pre-Turbo
#13
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (11)
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Birmingham, AL
Posts: 1,573
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
whats the logic in half the **** we do?!? hahaha
the way i see it is its kinda like the big superchargers that have to have the fuel running through them to "seal" up. i think it would help out with the turbo efficiency and also just be that much more cooling everything down. and i just want to... haha
i very well might be completely wrong but if i werent to have any solid proof not to do it id try it
the way i see it is its kinda like the big superchargers that have to have the fuel running through them to "seal" up. i think it would help out with the turbo efficiency and also just be that much more cooling everything down. and i just want to... haha
i very well might be completely wrong but if i werent to have any solid proof not to do it id try it
#14
TECH Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Crystal Springs, MS
Posts: 14,068
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
If it was a boltup turbo id like to try it on a On3 turbo and see what happens. Those things are only $340 shipped.
I dont wanna chance hurting my 900$ BW.
I dont wanna chance hurting my 900$ BW.
#15
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (11)
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Birmingham, AL
Posts: 1,573
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i can understand hurting the compressor blades spinning a a bajillion and a half rpm but the methanol eating up the aluminum doesnt concern me at all. its not like youre soaking the wheel in the meth for a week... youre spraying a fine mist over it for a few seconds then its instantly gone. and how is that any different than spraying it through an aluminum intake or into the aluminum heads..??
#16
TECH Senior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Crystal Springs, MS
Posts: 14,068
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Thats what i was wondering.
Everybody on YB said 99% of the spray mist is evaporated before it even comes out of the comp outlet.
And it has plenty of time to sling any residual liquid off the blades and dry out in half a second after the spray stops. So the only possible thing i could see it doin is causing more stress on the comp wheel having the mist hitting the blades at high rpms.
Its almost sounds oppiste what you would think since the water has to displace the air at some point. So it doesnt make sense that it makes the turbo more effecient. Unless the cooling effect takes over??
Everybody on YB said 99% of the spray mist is evaporated before it even comes out of the comp outlet.
And it has plenty of time to sling any residual liquid off the blades and dry out in half a second after the spray stops. So the only possible thing i could see it doin is causing more stress on the comp wheel having the mist hitting the blades at high rpms.
Its almost sounds oppiste what you would think since the water has to displace the air at some point. So it doesnt make sense that it makes the turbo more effecient. Unless the cooling effect takes over??
#17
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (26)
I have done a TON of research on this for my truck. Bottom line from the guys who have ACTUALLY done it is it works just fine and there is NO issues with erosion from friction OR meth. It just isn't in liquid form long enough. The benefit is you are cooling the air at the heated source, so you're putting cooler air into the intercooler so it can extract even more temp, until you are closer to being thermally neutral.
I have plans to do this some day, just have never gotten around to it. I'll be using a M5 pre-turbo and a M15 post.
I have plans to do this some day, just have never gotten around to it. I'll be using a M5 pre-turbo and a M15 post.
#19
GFYS and STFU
iTrader: (8)
Water is probably the worst fluid because it's the only non-compressible subsantce in the world. It's one of the primary reasons why it is used in water-jet machines.
I still think that regardless of nozzle atomization, line pressures used, and latent heat absorbtion from the intake charge that water will still be saturated and will cause blade errosion over time.
The combination of pressure and heat required to superheat any fluid will not be found prior to the impeller. Yes it won't cause immediate damage to the impeller but used enough, over time it will damage the impeller blades and at the very minimum hurt the efficiency of the blades.
I haven't touched the subject of fluid dynamics in over ten years, back when I thought I was smart, but I have a inherrent aversion to thinking it's ok to use water or any fluid pre-turbo. The only saving grace I see in any of this is most of what I learned about this had to do with steam turbines whose blades were 4-6 feet long which caused the blade tips to border on supersonic speeds. I'm not sure what the blade tip speed is on the turbo's we use is but maybe someone can do the math for us.
Just something I dug up prior to posting...
Tiny water hammers bash blades - physicsworld.com
I have done a TON of research on this for my truck. Bottom line from the guys who have ACTUALLY done it is it works just fine and there is NO issues with erosion from friction OR meth. It just isn't in liquid form long enough. The benefit is you are cooling the air at the heated source, so you're putting cooler air into the intercooler so it can extract even more temp, until you are closer to being thermally neutral.
I have plans to do this some day, just have never gotten around to it. I'll be using a M5 pre-turbo and a M15 post.
I have plans to do this some day, just have never gotten around to it. I'll be using a M5 pre-turbo and a M15 post.
The combination of pressure and heat required to superheat any fluid will not be found prior to the impeller. Yes it won't cause immediate damage to the impeller but used enough, over time it will damage the impeller blades and at the very minimum hurt the efficiency of the blades.
I haven't touched the subject of fluid dynamics in over ten years, back when I thought I was smart, but I have a inherrent aversion to thinking it's ok to use water or any fluid pre-turbo. The only saving grace I see in any of this is most of what I learned about this had to do with steam turbines whose blades were 4-6 feet long which caused the blade tips to border on supersonic speeds. I'm not sure what the blade tip speed is on the turbo's we use is but maybe someone can do the math for us.
Just something I dug up prior to posting...
Tiny water hammers bash blades - physicsworld.com
#20
TECH Junkie
iTrader: (9)
When I asked Julio at Alky-control about doing it on mine, he said not to until I was out of turbo. That plenty do it, but if you can easily raise the boost with the controller, leave the meth after the intercooler.
I would think it would help my ole ebay intercooler out by having the air that enters it cooler already. The nozzle you should use should allow for complete evaporation of the meth before leaving the turbo.
I would think it would help my ole ebay intercooler out by having the air that enters it cooler already. The nozzle you should use should allow for complete evaporation of the meth before leaving the turbo.