water injection vs alcohol injection vs intercooler.....
#1
water injection vs alcohol injection vs intercooler.....
Ok, I've been batting a few ideas around lately with regard to the radix and running more than the standard 6-7psi boost........
First = what is considered more desirable? water injection or alcohol injection?
why?
Second = in addition to the water/air intercooler that comes with the radix has anyone thought of adding an air/air intercooler? If you relocated the battery you could position the intake filter there, then have a clear path for tubing to the inlet side of the intercooler, then run the outlet directly to the magna charger inlet keeping bends to a min...
Third = If someone had a true cold air intake, air/air intercooler, water/air intercooler, and water injection what effect would it have on the CDT temp?
I might be crazy , but these are my thoughts as of late....
First = what is considered more desirable? water injection or alcohol injection?
why?
Second = in addition to the water/air intercooler that comes with the radix has anyone thought of adding an air/air intercooler? If you relocated the battery you could position the intake filter there, then have a clear path for tubing to the inlet side of the intercooler, then run the outlet directly to the magna charger inlet keeping bends to a min...
Third = If someone had a true cold air intake, air/air intercooler, water/air intercooler, and water injection what effect would it have on the CDT temp?
I might be crazy , but these are my thoughts as of late....
#2
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Houston,Tx
Posts: 1,843
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hopefully brian will chime in. i dont think you would need any thing beyond what the radix cooler would offer unles you are going to up the boost a lot.
i plan on running a air to water with water /alcohol injection for high boost track running. (about 20 psi)
as far as the water,alcohol. you will get mixed reviews on this. some people say it is a bandaid which i do not agree with. i have heard best results whe you have a mixture of water and alcohol. they will both cool thi IAT and the alcohol will add octane. i think it is an injenious way to make more power when typical intercooling will not sufice. you can run more timing, boost and also use say 93 octane gas.
propane injection is another oprion but i dont think it is any better than water/alky not sure though.
i plan on running a air to water with water /alcohol injection for high boost track running. (about 20 psi)
as far as the water,alcohol. you will get mixed reviews on this. some people say it is a bandaid which i do not agree with. i have heard best results whe you have a mixture of water and alcohol. they will both cool thi IAT and the alcohol will add octane. i think it is an injenious way to make more power when typical intercooling will not sufice. you can run more timing, boost and also use say 93 octane gas.
propane injection is another oprion but i dont think it is any better than water/alky not sure though.
Trending Topics
#8
blownerator
iTrader: (20)
the heat exchanger that you have is more than enough to handle the 8-9 psi you will be making.....The air to air intercooler will be next to impossible to do, you would benefit more from a custom cold air intake with a scoop in the lower valance.
I too have toyed with alcohol injection, the SMC kit to be exact. I feel it is a band aid for an improper tuned truck. It is more effective on a turbo set up IMO, I know dcarins is running it on his Radix....I just dont know about pulling that through the rotors.
I too have toyed with alcohol injection, the SMC kit to be exact. I feel it is a band aid for an improper tuned truck. It is more effective on a turbo set up IMO, I know dcarins is running it on his Radix....I just dont know about pulling that through the rotors.
#9
12 Second Truck Club
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Sacramento, CA
Posts: 5,575
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't see why meth injection would be a bandaid at all. Your worst enemy with any type of forced induction is heat. An intercooler helps to exchange some of the extra heat but it does so at a price namely loss of boost. This usually leads to adding more psi out of the blower/turbo which creates even more heat exponentially so it is almost a wash. With meth or water you don't have to up the boost at all which will create overall lower IATs than say adding a huge intercooler and adding boost to compensate.
My take on water vs. methanol is to make the kit actually work you must vaporize the liquid thus wicking away heat. Simply look at the temp in whicvh water boils vs methanol. Or take a lil water and put in the palm of your hand and watch how long it takes to evaporate. Now do the same with some rubbing alcohol. See which one evaporates faster and feels cooler while it's doing it? It's the same with heat in your intake charge. If you are interested I will look up a link to some tests done by some chemist guys in regards to meth injection.
The main reason for adding water is to keep costs down if you are using lots of it. OR to reduce the likelyhood of fire since methanol boils around 150deg and is highly flamable. It won't cool as well but for safety reasons it's not a bad idea.
I just think 100% water injection just leaves too much on the table and methanol isn't that expensive for our uses. i just picked up a 5ga jug for $38 which should last me about a month of normal use. Or more if I mix it.
My take on water vs. methanol is to make the kit actually work you must vaporize the liquid thus wicking away heat. Simply look at the temp in whicvh water boils vs methanol. Or take a lil water and put in the palm of your hand and watch how long it takes to evaporate. Now do the same with some rubbing alcohol. See which one evaporates faster and feels cooler while it's doing it? It's the same with heat in your intake charge. If you are interested I will look up a link to some tests done by some chemist guys in regards to meth injection.
The main reason for adding water is to keep costs down if you are using lots of it. OR to reduce the likelyhood of fire since methanol boils around 150deg and is highly flamable. It won't cool as well but for safety reasons it's not a bad idea.
I just think 100% water injection just leaves too much on the table and methanol isn't that expensive for our uses. i just picked up a 5ga jug for $38 which should last me about a month of normal use. Or more if I mix it.
#10
blownerator
iTrader: (20)
Originally Posted by F8LPONY
I don't see why meth injection would be a bandaid at all. Your worst enemy with any type of forced induction is heat. An intercooler helps to exchange some of the extra heat but it does so at a price namely loss of boost.