<TECH ONLY> DCR affects with LSA discussion
#13
Originally Posted by truckmann
Sport Side when I decide that I can afford a cam you are the guy I'm gonna hunt down for advice. You seem to really know your
#14
Originally Posted by Sport Side
Okay...
220/220 110LSA + 0 = 110ICL/110ECL
-Now tighten the LSA 2*, but keep the same ICL.
220/220 108LSA - 2 = 110ICL/106ECL
-The LSA tightened 2*, but the ICL remains the same.
... Therefore, no change in DCR
You can adjust LSA every which a way, but if the ICL remains the same there is no change in DCR.
ICL and intake duration are the two keys in DCR because these move the IVC.
You already know this. I think I'm missing something in your opening post.
220/220 110LSA + 0 = 110ICL/110ECL
-Now tighten the LSA 2*, but keep the same ICL.
220/220 108LSA - 2 = 110ICL/106ECL
-The LSA tightened 2*, but the ICL remains the same.
... Therefore, no change in DCR
You can adjust LSA every which a way, but if the ICL remains the same there is no change in DCR.
ICL and intake duration are the two keys in DCR because these move the IVC.
You already know this. I think I'm missing something in your opening post.
#15
He means that you can move the intake and exhaust lobes around in relation to each other any direction you choose, but if the centerline of the intake lobe stays the same in relation to the crank then the DCR will be the same.
#16
I was thinking that when you move the ECL closer to the ICL you would loose DC. I can't seem to think through what is happening. I'll do a little research online and see if I can find some pictures to post up.
I have a lot more reading to do, I don't want to mess up the thread with the newb questions. I'll come back more educated .
I have a lot more reading to do, I don't want to mess up the thread with the newb questions. I'll come back more educated .
Last edited by Stoichiometric; 04-04-2007 at 07:54 PM.
#17
Originally Posted by truckmann
Sport Side when I decide that I can afford a cam you are the guy I'm gonna hunt down for advice. You seem to really know your
#20
Originally Posted by TurboGibbs
Ok, I started drinking again so I could think more clearly.
Sportside is correct. It is all just a play on numbers. It really is affected by the moving of the intake centerline. If you widen the lsa and keep the same amount of advance on a cam then you get more bleed off....because the intake center line moved.
Sportside is correct. It is all just a play on numbers. It really is affected by the moving of the intake centerline. If you widen the lsa and keep the same amount of advance on a cam then you get more bleed off....because the intake center line moved.
BOTH LSA and ICL are important because LSA can effect the ICL (and ussually does unless you spec the lobes yourself, or tell your grinder you want this ICL and that LSA -- and the trade off you make there is by shifting ALL exhaust events, which in some cases won't be possible). Having said that, and as I understand DCR, the ICL is what actually can change *without replacing the cam shaft* the DCR. Retarding the ICL decreases DCR (delays IVC) and advancing the ICL increases ICL (accelerates IVC).
The IVC is what we should really be talking about, if we're getting down to brass tacks. IVC is determined by intake duration, ICL and LSA. ICL is virtually ignore when people talk about spec'ing a cam because it can be adjusted for (and people are freaked out about learning about cams for some reason).
Look at it like this:
After the power stroke, the exhaust valve pops open and the piston pushes the exhausted cylinder charge out as it moves towards TDC. At some point as the piston moves back towards BDC (depending on the cam geometry) the intake valve opens and the exhaust valve closes (these may occur IVO .. time .. EVC and this is the 'overlap' we hear so much about). When the piston reaches BDC and starts moving back up (at the start of the compression stroke) the intake valve is still open and still sucking in charge. At IVC, some portion of the cylinder volume is left (remember there is NO compression yet as the intake valve just closed) and that volume is what we need to calculate the DCR (as opposed to the total cylinder volume used to calculate the SCR).
Another way to say this is that the SCR uses the full stroke of the crank, and the DCR uses only the portion of the full stroke that is actually used to compress the cylinder charge.
I've always heard that street engines (e.g. non-race gas) are best with 7.5 - 8.5:1 DCR and that anything over 8.25:1 requires exacting detail in the build and piston design (quench needs to be at the lower limit when running high DCRs) and must be run cooler than lower DCRs (or lowered timing). I've also heard that race engines use DCRs of 8.8 - 9:1.
As you can guess from the numbers I've heard and what Mark has heard, there are no real hard and fast rules for DCR.
Here is a handy chart posted by Zick in another thread:
I've read that DCR doesn't care about boost, so you have to adjust your DCR to accommodate the extra pressure. To do that you multiply your DCR by your pressure ratio (14.7 + boost / 14.7). You still want to be in that 7.5 - 8.5 range after the multiplication. But that means running 18psi is 12.xx DCR for me (8.65:1) and I don't believe that number. I can't seem to find an authoritative answer on boost DCR -- but as Mark suggested way back when
Originally Posted by TurboGibbs
Or you could skip all the #'s and use the old school method. Make sure you have a good stout short block then push it till mild detonation, then you back off. It has worked for years for many/most. I prefer to stick to the old methods, call me simple minded.
If you push the envelope without good parts then carniage you may have.
If you push the envelope without good parts then carniage you may have.